The Spring 2009 Hatchet is ONLINE!

This the place to have frank, but cordial, discussions of the Lizzie Borden case

Moderator: Adminlizzieborden

mbhenty
Posts: 4474
Joined: Wed Feb 15, 2006 1:20 am
Real Name:

Post by mbhenty »

:smile:


Yes, Thank you Augusta. Yep, thays be errors. It should read "silver".

Sakonnet Point is about my late night approach of the Newport, R.I. coast from a weekend trip I took to Cuttyhunk Island. The Light at Sakonnet Point guided me safely into Sachuest Point and Third Beach in Newport.

Newport Gleam is about a peaceful evening and night anchored in Sachuest Cove. Very peaceful place to anchor. The anchorage overlooks sandy 3rd Beach in Newport.

When I received an Email from Stefani asking me if I had anything to contribute to the Hatchet and I did not. So I dug up these two somewhat unfinished poems, polished them up a bit and sent them along. In the quick translation a spelling error or two got by and it was probably my fault.

Of the three main beaches in Newport, Third beach is the furthest away from downtown and the quietest.

To give you an idea where I am talking about here is some eye candy below:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
augusta
Posts: 2231
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2004 11:27 am
Gender: Female
Real Name: Augusta
Location: USA

Post by augusta »

I loved David Marshall James' "Mesdemoiselles of French Street in 'The Adventure of the Green Cape'"! I thought it was fun, and funny, and bright and refreshing. Just a pleasure to read. Thank you, David. I hope we see more of your fiction in future issues. :grin:

Thanks for posting the photo and little map, mb. I could go to that beach. It looks very inviting. It's great to see a photo of the place you wrote about. It does look special.
ddnoe
Posts: 151
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 5:39 pm
Real Name:

Post by ddnoe »

augusta @ Sat May 30, 2009 2:47 pm wrote:This issue's 'Meet the Author' on page 78 featured Kat Koorey. I so enjoyed it! :sunny: It was interesting to read her insightful answers. Her disinterest in owning Maplecroft was an eye opener to me. I think she's right about getting inside. That does make me put it more in the back of my mind than as it used to be, in the front. I could have easily read more yet on Kat's views and interesting life. Beautiful picture, too! I tell my husband that Kat is "an ageless beauty".

I read Denise Noe's Whittlings on "Bible Readings at Lizzie Borden's Funeral" (page 70). I think it was a good topic for her to cover. I dug into it with gusto, but found myself a bit disappointed in a few areas.

I think she may have been best off talking to an Episcopal priest, since that was Lizzie's last organized professed religion. (I think her cousin, Grace Howe went to the Church of Ascension and may have had something to do with Lizzie affiliating herself there.) Bible interpretations are many and varied, depending on who you talk to. She may have gotten different answers from an Episcopal priest, or an Episcopal website.

The instructions Lizzie wrote out for her funeral may have only been part of her service. She was laid out at Maplecroft, and there is nothing to say that she did not receive full Burial Rites at her home.

The Book of Common Prayer that was in use by Episcopalians at that time held only one version of Burial Rites. (Today the book offers two different ones.) I brought that subject up in a past post on the Forum and I think I gave a link to that old prayer book as well. So if she did receive the Burial Rites, that would have been the one that was used.

When an Episcopal funeral takes place today, and I've been to too many, the next of kin - or better yet, instructions left by the deceased - are asked to choose two readings from the Bible. And they also - kin or deceased - choose what hymn(s) they wanted sung.

I know the graveside service was very short, and I think Lizzie's preferred verses only were said there, and very possibly the Burial Rite was said at home, but I have no proof.

The comment is made in the article that "the specific custom of 'anointing' has long since passed"... and that people can experience it in a metaphorical sense. Had she talked to an Episcopal priest, she would have found out that this is not true. They still do anointing with oil when someone is ill. I don't know about other religions, but in this case we are talking about the Episcopal faith.

The explanation of the meaning of what "sheep" are is off base in the Episcopal interpretation. We are taught that we are all God's sheep and he is our shepherd. Sheep follow the shepherd. There is the parable (Bible story) of 'The Lost Sheep' that gives a good example of what us being 'sheep' means. I don't think Dr. Tedder's interpretation is wrong, but it seems to go a little deeper than that with the Episcopal church.

I had never heard of "my cup runneth over" meaning it runs over with anointing oil. To me, that doesn't make sense. I've always taken it another way - that we are blessed with so many things, if we tried to contain them in a chalice, they would not all fit. You have more blessings that you can count.

I would have liked to have seen Lizzie's funeral described.

I thought Denise's summation about Lizzie was very good. And her overall writing excellent.

I applaud Denise for taking this task on, and for her unbiased writing of the article, which was a needed talent for this article. :cheers:
(Denise) Thank you, Augusta, for your well-taken and well-informed criticisms. I don't have time to address them in this post but thank you for drawing my attention to areas in which I may have been incomplete or simply mistaken. Thank you also for your compliments.
augusta
Posts: 2231
Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2004 11:27 am
Gender: Female
Real Name: Augusta
Location: USA

Post by augusta »

Denise, I am glad you know me well enough to know that any negative criticisms were in no way personal. They never are to anyone. If I wasn't Episcopalian, I probably wouldn't have known those tidbits. Since you are not a church-goer, it is totally understandable why you might miss some of those things. And it is all the more commendable for you to take the subject on.

I think you show your professionalism by how you take criticism. That is just one more thing that makes you the excellent writer that you are. :smile:
User avatar
Tina-Kate
Posts: 1465
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2004 11:08 pm
Real Name:
Location: South East Canada

Post by Tina-Kate »

Just got mine this morning.

Time to dig in.

:grin:
“I am innocent. I leave it to my counsel to speak for me.”
—Lizzie A. Borden, June 20, 1893
User avatar
Tina-Kate
Posts: 1465
Joined: Thu Apr 22, 2004 11:08 pm
Real Name:
Location: South East Canada

Post by Tina-Kate »

Loved Kat's The Medium is the Message. Coincidentally, I just finished reading Sarah Water's Affinity, which is about a grieving woman in 1870s London who decides to volunteer to visit female prisoners in London's Millbank Prison (since the turn of the 19th/20th century, this is now the site of the marvellous Tate Britain Gallery). She befriends a prisoner who is a trance medium. I love Sarah Water's writing; she takes you right back in time.

I had also recently watched a movie about Houdini...so this article was wonderfully interesting. Thanks Kat!

Oooh! Mustn't forget to mention Dear Abby. I was laughing out loud even after I put it down. Great job, Sherry!
“I am innocent. I leave it to my counsel to speak for me.”
—Lizzie A. Borden, June 20, 1893
Post Reply