Wealth As Motive

[MysteryReader]

I think it was financial. Both on Lizzie's part, and if someone else did it, Andy probably owed money to someone.
Here's this scenrio. Person comes over to get the money he feels owed to him. Andrew feels he paid the person the money he was owed. A fight starts, with Andy getting the blade.

That's a nice theory Snokkums, but does Andrew get killed first? Who kills Abby then- the same person or someone else?

[debbiediablo]

If it was strictly about unpaid debt (and I do not ascribe to this theory) then I see Andrew as the lender, not the borrower.

[MysteryReader]

I agree, Debbie. I don't ascribe to it either but it is a nice theory.

[twinsrwe]

Murder is the ultimate means of control.

You are absolutely right, Debbie!!!